Dak Prescott’s Contract: What It Means for the Cowboys and the NFL’s Future
How Timing, Market Value, and Stability at Quarterback Shape the Economics of the Game
Hey all, Astro Joe Garcia here again! I am so glad the Cowboys got a W in week 1. But let’s talk about the Dak Prescott big news! I’ll be the first to say it—I’m glad this Dak Prescott contract situation is finally resolved. As a Cowboys fan, watching the back-and-forth, hearing the rumors, and reading the commentary can be exhausting. But here we are, with Dak locked in. And with his no-trade clause and a no-franchise-tag clause, it was a deal that left Dallas with little choice but to get things done.
Let’s break it down, because this deal says a lot more about the NFL’s economics, team strategies, and the pressure cooker of being an elite quarterback in today’s game than it does about Dak himself.
What Does No-Trade and No-Franchise-Tag Mean?
For starters, these clauses matter. A no-trade clause gives the player control. Essentially, Dak had the power to block any trade the Cowboys may propose. Without his consent, he was not going anywhere. The no-franchise-tag clause? That one ensures that when his contract expires, Dallas can’t simply slap a franchise tag on him to buy more time. He would hit free agency, free to test the waters.
Franchise tags exist as a way for teams to retain top talent when a contract expires without fully committing to a long-term deal. The team places the tag on a player for one year, and that player earns the average salary of the top five players at their position. For a quarterback, that’s serious cash. But for Dak, knowing he had this leverage in the deal made it crystal clear: either Dallas commits, or he walks.
The Market for Top-Tier Players: Who Decides Their Worth?
Here’s the thing about Dak’s contract—it’s not just about Dak. It’s about what the market is saying quarterbacks are worth right now. But who determines that? The answer is a mix of factors: player agents, team front offices, and the broader economics of the NFL. A top-tier player—defined as someone who is consistently a top performer, a leader on and off the field, and key to a team’s success—often sets the market for others at their position. Teams will compare players, look at their stats, their playoff performance, and what others are getting paid. It’s a constant game of leapfrog.
Right now, quarterbacks like Joe Burrow and Trevor Lawrence are setting the bar. Dak recently became the highest-paid player in NFL history with his four-year, $240 million extension, boasting an $80 million signing bonus and $231 million guaranteed. He’s now making $60 million annually. Before Dak’s deal, Lawrence had signed a five-year, $275 million extension with the Jaguars, averaging $55 million per year, which ties him with Burrow for the second-highest annual salary.
But here’s a wild stat: how many of the quarterbacks earning over $50 million have a winning playoff record? Only Mahomes. The rest—Lawrence, Burrow, Justin Herbert, Lamar Jackson, and Jalen Hurts—either have struggled in the playoffs or haven't had enough postseason experience.
This is where things get tricky. Market value for quarterbacks isn’t always correlated with Super Bowl wins or playoff success. Teams are paying for stability, their potential and the ability to consistently keep them in the playoff mix. The Cowboys know Dak gives them that, and they’re betting on his stability.
The NFL Economics: The Sky’s the Limit
Let’s zoom out a bit and talk about the broader economics of the NFL. Every year, we see the valuation of teams go up, the TV deals get bigger, ticket prices soar, and teams explore new ways to rake in more cash. Whether it's through merchandise, partnerships, or exclusive 360-degree deals, the NFL is a money-making machine. Forbes reported that the Cowboys are worth over $11 billion ($3 billion more than the next team)—yes, with a "B." The business side of the game is booming, and players want their slice of that pie.
This is why contracts like Dak’s happen. The pie keeps getting bigger, the salary cap keeps increasing, so the slices for the stars are growing too. Players like Dak are maximizing their worth in an ever-growing league. Can you blame him? Owners sure aren’t shy about trying to cut costs where they can.
Why Timing Matters: Signing Early vs. Last-Minute Deals
One of the big lessons from Dak’s deal is the importance of timing, not just in negotiations but within the NFL year itself. The NFL operates on a financial calendar with key deadlines—free agency, the start of the new league year in March, and roster bonus dates. If teams handle contracts proactively before these dates, they can save serious money.
For example, the Cowboys could have signed Dak earlier in his career or even before the 2024 NFL league year started. By signing before the market exploded with deals for players like Jalen Hurts, Joe Burrow, and Trevor Lawrence, Dallas could have locked in Dak at a lower rate. Every time the Cowboys waited, the price tag for top-tier quarterbacks went up. The same goes for CeeDee Lamb, who recently signed a four-year, $136 million extension with $38 million guaranteed. Earlier action could have saved the Cowboys millions by avoiding having to compete with escalating contracts in future offseasons.
Timing isn’t just about locking in a deal—it’s also about spreading out salary cap hits. If Dallas had restructured Dak's deal or extended him earlier, they could have had more flexibility to maneuver under the salary cap. This could allow the team to push bonus money into future years, reduce immediate hits, and open up cap space for other signings or extensions.
By handling these contracts before the key deadlines, like the start of the NFL year or training camp, teams can save on the inevitable inflation of player salaries. Getting ahead of the market is a strategic move—one the Cowboys could have benefitted from both with Dak and as they look ahead to Parsons and others. Had the Cowboys followed a path similar to what the Eagles did with Jalen Hurts, they might have secured a better deal for their franchise quarterback and maintained more cap space to keep building a competitive roster.
Stability at Quarterback Is Priceless
I can’t stress this enough—having a reliable, steady quarterback is everything. Look, the Cowboys could have tried to draft someone like Shedeur Sanders or traded up for a new QB, but what would that cost them? They would have had to tank this season or give up future draft picks, and you never know if a rookie will pan out. For every Mahomes, there’s a string of QBs who looked great on draft day but flamed out.
The Cowboys lived through quarterback purgatory in the early 2000s after Troy Aikman retired. It wasn’t until Tony Romo and Dak came along that Dallas found some stability. Do we really want to go back to that? Sure, people say, “But Dak hasn’t won the big one.” True. But by that logic, only Mahomes or Brady would ever be worthy of their contracts. John Elway didn’t win until late in his career. Dan Marino never won a Super Bowl, but he’s still considered one of the greatest QBs of all time. And no I’m not saying Dak is as good as these two icons, but he still has a chance to get there.
Lessons for the Future: Parsons and Beyond
Here’s what this deal with Dak should teach us, especially as we look ahead to future negotiations with guys like Micah Parsons. You’ve got to be proactive. When you know a player is worth it, make the deal early. Waiting only makes things more expensive.
And for those who criticize Dak for his contract, let’s remember that he’s just playing the game. The market dictates his value. If the Cowboys didn’t pay him, another team would have. Players have a right to get the most out of their careers, just like owners try to get the most out of their investments.
Looking Ahead
At the end of the day, there will always be people who love this move and others who can’t wait to see Dak fail. But me? I’m a glass-half-full guy. Let’s see what he does. Cowboys fans have been saying “this is the year” for nearly 30 years now. Maybe, just maybe, Dak is the one who gets us there.
But whatever happens, at least we’re not back in quarterback purgatory. I’m grateful for that. And as we look forward to the season, there’s one thing I’ve learned after following the Cowboys and the NFL for all these years: EVERY day is a celebration. Whether it’s a big win, a tough loss, or just the anticipation of what’s to come, there’s always something to appreciate.
So, here’s to another season. Let’s see what Dak and the Cowboys do with this one!
May your favorite team do a better job at signing their top tier players than the Cowboys do!
Salud,
Astro Joe Garcia
I Wanna Be A Cowboy - Boys Don’t Cry